1. Platform Features
Abu na farko da za mu kwatanta shi ne fasalin dandamali, wanda ya haɗa da haɗin kai na gabaɗaya da amfani, kayan aikin ciniki da kayan aiki, damar sarrafa kansa da algorithmic ciniki, da cinikin wayar hannu da zaɓuɓɓukan samun dama.
1.1. Gabaɗaya Interface & Amfani
The mai amfani (UI) da kuma kwarewar mai amfani (UX) na dandalin ciniki abubuwa ne masu mahimmanci waɗanda ke shafar sauƙin amfani, zaɓuɓɓukan gyare-gyare, kewayawa, da kuma tsarin tsarin dandamali.
MT4:
MT4 yana da sauki kuma ilhama UI wanda ke da sauƙin amfani ga masu farawa da gogaggen traders daidai. Dandalin yana da ƙirar gargajiya wanda ya ƙunshi hudu manyan windows:
- Kallon kasuwa,
- Tagar taga,
- Tashar,
- Navigator,
Dandalin yana ba masu amfani damar siffanta bayyanar, launuka, fonts, da jigogi na UI, da kuma tsara windows da shafuka bisa ga abubuwan da suke so. MT4 kuma yana da a sashin taimako da aka gina a ciki kuma a jagorar mai amfani wanda ke bayyana mahimman ayyuka da fasali na dandamali.
cTrader:
cTrader yana da fiye UI na zamani da nagartaccen tsari don ci gaba traders neman ƙarin ayyuka da sassauci. Dandalin yana da a sleek da ƙarancin ƙira hada uku manyan sassan:
- Tagar taga,
- The trade kallo,
- Menu na gefe,
Dandalin yana ba masu amfani damar siffanta UI tare da fatu daban-daban, shimfidu, samfuri, da widget din kuma suna cirewa da sake girman tagogi da fanai gwargwadon bukatunsu. cTrader kuma a m cibiyar taimako kuma a mai amfani forum wanda ke ba da tallafi da jagora ga masu amfani da dandamali.
Dukansu dandamali sun dace da matakan gogewa daban-daban, dangane da abubuwan da mai amfani ke so da salon ciniki. MT4 ya dace don traders waɗanda suka fi son dandamali mai sauƙi kuma sananne wanda ke ba da mahimman fasali da kayan aiki don ciniki. cTrader shine manufa don traders waɗanda suka fi son ingantaccen dandamali mai sauƙi da sauƙi wanda ke ba da ƙarin fasali da kayan aiki don ciniki.
Platform | UI Zane | gyare-gyare | Sauƙi na amfani | Cancanta |
MT4 | Sauƙi kuma na gargajiya | matsakaici | high | Mai fara zuwa tsaka-tsaki |
cTrader | Na zamani da na zamani | high | matsakaici | Matsakaici zuwa ci gaba |
1.2. Kayayyakin Kasuwanci & Kayan Aiki
Kayan aikin ciniki da kayan aiki na dandalin ciniki sune mahimman abubuwan da suka shafi aikin ciniki, bincike, da dabarun trader.
MT4:
MT4 yana goyan bayan nau'ikan kayan ciniki daban-daban, gami da forex, CFDs akan fihirisa, kayayyaki, karafa, kuzari, hannun jari, da cryptocurrencies. Dandalin yayi uku na asali tsari iri:
- Kasuwa,
- Iyaka,
- Dakatar da umarni.
Akwai kuma hanyoyin aiwatarwa guda huɗu: nan take, nema, kasuwa, da musayar. Dandalin kuma yana ba da kayan aikin ƙira daban-daban, kamar tara lokaci, nau'ikan ginshiƙi uku, kayan aikin zane 31, da kuma 24 abubuwa masu hoto. Dandalin yana da 30 ginannen alamun fasaha, da kuma dubban alamu na al'ada da ke samuwa daga MetaTrader Kasuwa da al'ummar MQL4. Dandalin kuma yana da wasu iyawar nazari, kamar kalandar tattalin arziki, abincin labarai, da agogon kasuwa.
cTrader:
cTrader yana goyan bayan irin wannan kewayon kayan ciniki kamar yadda MT4, dangane da brokerbayarwa. Dandalin yayi oda na ci gaba shida iri:
- Kasuwa,
- Iyaka,
- Tsaya,
- Tsaya iyaka,
- Kewayon kasuwa,
akwai nau'ikan kariya guda hudu: riba, dakatar da hasara, tsayawa tasha, da karya koda. Dandalin kuma yana ba da kayan aikin ƙira daban-daban, kamar 28 timeframes, takwas chart iri, 70 zane kayan aikin, da kuma 55 abubuwa masu hoto. Dandalin yana da 65 ginannen alamun fasaha, da kuma ɗaruruwan alamomin al'ada da ake samu daga cTrader al'umma da kuma cTrader API ta atomatik. Dandalin kuma yana da wasu iyawar nazari, kamar tunanin kasuwa, zurfin kasuwa, trade kididdiga, da kuma trade watch.
Dukansu dandamali suna ba da cikakkiyar saiti na kayan aikin ciniki da kayan aiki, amma cTrader yana da wasu siffofi na musamman da tallavantageya wuce MT4. cTrader yana ba da ƙarin nau'ikan tsari da nau'ikan kariya, da kuma ƙarin lokutan lokaci da nau'ikan ginshiƙi. cTrader kuma yana alfahari da wasu keɓaɓɓun fasali, kamar zurfin kasuwa, wanda ke nuna liquidity da kuma yawan kasuwa, da kuma yadda kasuwar ke nunawa, wanda ke nuna yawan masu saye da masu sayarwa a kasuwa.
Platform | Instruments | Order Types | Kayan aikin Charting | Technical Manuniya | Ƙarfin nazari |
MT4 | Forex, CFDs akan fihirisa, kayayyaki, karafa, kuzari, hannun jari, da cryptocurrencies | Kasuwa, iyaka, da dakatar da oda | 9 lokaci, nau'ikan ginshiƙi 3, kayan aikin zane 31, da abubuwa masu hoto 24 | 30 ginannen, dubban al'ada | Kalanda na tattalin arziki, ciyarwar labarai, kallon kasuwa |
cTrader | Forex, CFDs akan fihirisa, kayayyaki, karafa, kuzari, hannun jari, da cryptocurrencies | Kasuwa, iyaka, tsayawa, iyakar tsayawa, kewayon kasuwa, da umarnin aiwatar da kasuwa | 28 lokaci, nau'ikan ginshiƙi 8, kayan aikin zane 70, da abubuwa masu hoto 55 | 64 ginannen ciki, ɗaruruwan al'ada | Hankalin kasuwa, zurfin kasuwa, trade ƙididdiga, trade duba |
1.3. Automation & Algorithmic Trading
Ƙimar dandamali ta ciniki da ikon ciniki na algorithmic abubuwa ne masu mahimmanci waɗanda ke shafar aiki da kai, haɓakawa, da gwaji na ciniki dabaru. Ƙarfin ciniki ta atomatik da algorithmic sun haɗa da harsunan rubutun rubutu, kayan aikin goyan baya, da EA (gwani Bayar Da Shawarar) dacewa.
MT4:
MT4 sananne ne da shi aiki da kai da kuma algorithmic ciniki damar, wanda ake amfani da su MetaQuotes Harshe 4 (MQL4), harshen rubutun mallakar mallaka wanda ke ba masu amfani damar ƙirƙira, gyara, da gudanar da shirye-shiryen ciniki na atomatik, kamar EAs, alamomin al'ada, da rubutun. Dandalin kuma yana bada a ginannen Dabarun Gwajin, wanda ke ba masu amfani damar sake gwadawa, ingantawa, da kuma lalata EAs ta amfani da bayanan tarihi da sigogin gwaji daban-daban. Hakanan yana goyan bayan MetaTrader Kasuwa, wanda shine kantin sayar da kan layi inda masu amfani zasu iya siya, siyarwa, ko hayar EAs, alamomin al'ada, da sauran aikace-aikacen ciniki.
cTrader:
cTrader kuma yana da m aiki da kai da kuma algorithmic ciniki damar, wanda ake amfani da su cTrader atomatik module, Haɗaɗɗen fasalin da ke ba masu amfani damar ƙirƙira, gyara, da gudanar da shirye-shiryen ciniki na atomatik, irin su cBots, alamun al'ada, da rubutun. Dandalin kuma yana bada a ginanniyar Backtesting da kuma Kayan aikin ingantawa, wanda ke ba masu amfani damar gwadawa, ingantawa, da kuma zana cBots ta amfani da bayanan tarihi da sigogin gwaji daban-daban. Hakanan yana goyan bayan cTrader API ta atomatik, wanda shine tsarin tushen budewa wanda ke ba masu amfani damar shiga, haɗawa, da kuma tsawaita cTrader Ayyuka ta atomatik.
Dukansu dandamali suna ba da ikon sarrafa kansa mai ƙarfi da ikon ciniki na algorithmic, amma cTrader yana da wasu iyakoki da tallavantageya wuce MT4. cTrader yana da yaren rubutu na zamani kuma mai sauƙin amfani, wanda ya dogara da C#, yaren shirye-shirye da yawa da ake amfani da shi. cTrader kuma yana da ƙarin ci gaba da sassauƙan gwajin baya da haɓakawa, wanda ke ba masu amfani damar yin gwajin gani na gani, kaska bayanan baya, da inganta kwayoyin halitta. Duk da haka, cTrader yana da ƙaramin ɗakin karatu da ƙarancin bambance-bambancen shirye-shiryen ciniki mai sarrafa kansa, da ƙarancin daidaituwa tare da EAs, waɗanda suka fi shahara kuma ana amfani da su sosai fiye da cBots.
Platform | Harshen Rubutu | Kayan aikin Bayarwa | Daidaituwar EA | Laburare Shirin Kasuwanci |
MT4 | MQL4 | Gwajin Dabarun | high | MetaTrader Kasuwa |
cTrader | C# | Bayarwa da Ingantawa | low | cTrader API ta atomatik |
2. Kasuwancin Wayar hannu & Samun Dama
Kasuwancin wayar hannu da zaɓuɓɓukan samun dama na dandalin ciniki sune mahimman abubuwan da suka shafi dacewa, motsi, da wadatar dandamali.
MT4:
MT4 yana da a sigar wayar hannu akwai don na'urorin iOS da Android, da kuma allunan. Aikace-aikacen wayar hannu yana ba masu amfani damar shiga asusun kasuwancin su, aiwatar da umarni, duba sigogi da alamomi, saka idanu kan kasuwa, da sarrafa matsayinsu. Hakanan app ɗin wayar hannu yana goyan bayan hanyar layi ta layi, wanda ke ba masu amfani damar duba tarihin asusun su, buɗaɗɗen matsayi, da oda masu jiran aiki ba tare da haɗin intanet ba. Yana kuma bayar da real-lokaci updates, wanda ke ba masu amfani damar karɓar sanarwar turawa, faɗakarwar labarai, da alamun kasuwa. Aikace-aikacen wayar hannu ya dace da tebur na dandamali da nau'ikan gidan yanar gizo, yana ba masu amfani damar daidaita saitunan su, abubuwan da suke so, da bayanai a cikin na'urori daban-daban.
cTrader:
cTrader kuma a sigar wayar hannu wanda yake samuwa ga na'urorin iOS da Android. Wannan app yana bawa masu amfani damar shiga asusun kasuwancin su, aiwatar da oda, duba sigogi da alamomi, saka idanu kan kasuwa, da sarrafa matsayinsu. The mobile app kuma yana bayar da real-lokaci updates, wanda ke ba masu amfani damar karɓar sanarwar turawa, faɗakarwar labarai, da alamun kasuwa.
Dukansu dandamali suna ba da ciniki iri ɗaya na wayar hannu da zaɓuɓɓukan samun dama, amma cTrader yana da tallavantages da kasawavantageya wuce MT4. cTrader yana ba da ƙarin UI na zamani da mai amfani, da ƙarin ci gaba da zane-zane da kayan aikin ciniki. Duk da haka, cTrader kuma yana da ƙananan samuwa da bambancin brokers da na'urori, da kuma ƙarancin kasuwa da shaharar dandamali.
Platform | mobile App | Samun Intanet | Sabunta-lokaci | Karfin dandamali |
MT4 | IOS, Android, Allunan | A | A | Desktop, Yanar Gizo |
cTrader | IOS, Android, Allunan | A'a | A | Desktop, Yanar Gizo |
3. Kudade & Kwamitocin
Kudade da kwamitocin dandalin ciniki abubuwa ne masu mahimmanci waɗanda ke shafar riba, araha, da bayyana gaskiya na dandamali. Kudade da kwamitocin sun haɗa da yadawa, mafi ƙarancin asusun, kuɗin rashin aiki, da kowane ƙarin caji.
MT4:
MT4 ba ya cajin duk wani kudade na dandamali ko kwamitocin, kamar yadda dandamali yana da kyauta don saukewa da amfani. Yana samar da kuɗi ta hanyar sayar da lasisinsa brokers. Koyaya, kudaden ciniki da kwamitocin sun dogara da brokersamfurin farashi da nau'in asusun. Yawanci, MT4 brokers bayar da nau'ikan asusu guda biyu: Standard da ECN. Daidaitaccen asusun suna da mafi girma shimfidawa amma babu kwamitocin, yayin da asusun ECN ke da ƙananan shimfidawa amma cajin kwamitocin kowane trade. MT4 kuma yana buƙatar ƙaramin ajiya na $/€/£10 don fara ciniki akan dandamali. The brokers akan MT4 kuma na iya cajin kuɗaɗen rashin aiki, wanda ke tsakanin $0 zuwa $50 kowace wata, ya danganta da broker da ayyukan asusun.
cTrader:
cTrader kuma ya aikata ba Yi cajin saukewa ko rajista. Koyaya, kudade da kwamitocin sun dogara da brokersamfurin farashi da nau'in asusun. Yawanci, cTrader brokers bayar da nau'in asusu guda ɗaya kawai: ECN. ECN asusun suna da ƙananan shimfidawa amma cajin kwamitocin kowane trade. Matsakaicin kwamiti na cTrader asusun yana kusa da 0.2 don majors da 3.50 kowace kuri'a. cTrader brokers kuma na iya cajin kuɗaɗen rashin aiki, wanda ke tsakanin $0 zuwa $30 kowace wata, ya danganta da na broker da ayyukan asusun.
Dukkanin dandamali suna da kudade iri ɗaya da kwamitocin, amma cTrader yana da tallavantages da kasawavantageya wuce MT4. The brokersa a cTrader bayar da ƙananan shimfidawa da kwamitocin, wanda zai iya haifar da ƙananan farashin ciniki da riba mai girma. Koyaya, suna kuma da mafi ƙarancin asusu da kuɗaɗen rashin aiki, wanda zai iya haɓaka nauyin kuɗi da hadarin domin traders. cTrader kuma yana da ƙarancin bambancin asusu da sassauci, saboda yana ba da asusun ECN kawai, yayin da MT4 ke ba da ma'auni da asusun ECN duka.
Platform | shimfidawa | kwamitocin | Mafi ƙarancin Asusu | Kudin Rashin Aiki | Bambancin Asusu |
MT4 | Mafi girma | Babu ko ƙasa | Lower | Mafi girma | Mafi girma |
cTrader | Lower | Lower | Mafi girma | Lower | Lower |
4. Broker karfinsu
The broker dacewa da dandalin ciniki muhimmin abu ne wanda ke shafar samuwa, bambancin, da ingancin dandalin. Broker dacewa ya haɗa da kewayon brokerya dace da kowane dandamali, iyakance ko tallavantages dangane da broker zabi, da kuma samuwar asusun demo da aiwatar da zaɓuɓɓukan ciniki.
MT4:
MT4 ya dace da adadi mai yawa na brokers, kamar yadda aka fi amfani da shi kuma shahararren dandalin ciniki a cikin masana'antu. Jimlar adadin masu aiki da marasa aiki brokers a MT4 ya bambanta tsakanin 1,200 da 3,000. Wannan yana nufin cewa traders suna da faffadan zaɓuɓɓuka da dama don zaɓar a broker wanda ya dace da bukatunsu da abubuwan da suke so. Duk da haka, wannan kuma yana nufin cewa traders ya zama mai hankali da himma lokacin zabar a broker, kamar yadda ba duk MT4 ba brokers amintattu ne, masu daraja, kuma ana tsara su. MT4 kuma yana goyan bayan asusun demo da aiwatar da zaɓuɓɓukan ciniki, waɗanda ke ba da izini traders don gwada dandamali da kuma brokersabis ɗin ba tare da haɗarin kuɗi na gaske ba.
cTrader:
cTrader ya dace da a ƙarami lamba of brokers, domin shi ne mafi alkuki da keɓantaccen dandalin ciniki a cikin masana'antar. Akwai a kusa da cTrader, wanda ke da fiye da 100 brokers a duniya kamar na 2024, wanda ke lissafin ƙasa da 10% na duniya forex kasuwar kasuwa. Wannan yana nufin haka traders suna da iyakataccen zaɓuɓɓuka da dama don zaɓar a broker wanda ya dace da bukatunsu da abubuwan da suke so. cTrader kuma yana goyan bayan demo asusun da aiwatar da zaɓuɓɓukan ciniki.
Dukansu dandamali suna da matakan daban-daban na broker dacewa, amma cTrader yana da wasu iyakoki da tallavantageya wuce MT4. cTrader yana ba da inganci mafi girma da amincin brokers, kazalika da daidaito da daidaiton ƙwarewar ciniki a tsakanin daban-daban brokers. Duk da haka, cTrader kuma yana ba da ƙarancin samuwa da bambancin brokers, da kuma ƙarancin kasuwa da shaharar dandamali.
Platform | Yawan Brokers | Ingancin Brokers | Bambance-bambancen na Brokers | Asusun Demo | Kwarewar Kasuwanci |
MT4 | a kan 1,300 | m | high | A | A |
cTrader | a kan 100 | high | low | A | A |
5. Tsaro & Amincewa
Tsaro da amincin dandalin ciniki sune mahimman abubuwan da suka shafi aminci, amincewa, da amincewar dandamali. Tsaro da aminci sun haɗa da fasalulluka na tsaro, kwanciyar hankali na dandamali, lokacin aiki, da tarihin tarihin abubuwan fasaha.
MT4:
MT4 yana da inganci tsaro da aminci, kamar yadda ake amfani da shi fasahar boye-boye masu zaman kansu don kare watsa bayanai tsakanin dandamali da uwar garken. Dandalin kuma ya bi ka'idodin masana'antu da ka'idoji. Hakanan yana da tsayayyen aiki mai ƙarfi, saboda yana iya ɗaukar dubunnan umarni a sakan daya da miliyoyin masu amfani a lokaci guda. Hakanan yana da a high uptime, kamar yadda ba kasafai ake samun raguwar lokaci ko fita ba. Har ila yau, dandalin yana da dogon lokaci da kuma tabbatar da tarihin gyara matsalolin fasaha da sauri, kamar yadda yake aiki tun 2005 kuma yana ci gaba da sabuntawa da ingantawa.
cTrader:
cTrader kuma yana da babban tsaro da aminci, kamar yadda yake amfani da shi amintattu kuma amintattun sabobin don aiwatar da ma'amaloli. Haka kuma, yana da barga da sauri yi, Kamar yadda yake amfani da fasaha na girgije da kuma rarraba gine-gine don tabbatar da ƙananan latency da babban haɓaka.
Dukansu dandamali suna ba da babban matakin tsaro da aminci, amma cTrader yana da tallavantages da kasawavantageya wuce MT4. cTrader yana ba da babban matakin ɓoyewa, wanda zai iya haifar da mafi girman kariyar bayanai da keɓantawa. Duk da haka, cTrader kuma yana da gajeriyar rikodin waƙa na al'amuran fasaha, saboda sabon dandamali ne kuma ƙasa da balagagge fiye da MT4.
Platform | yarda | Performance | Kyau | Rikodin Waƙa |
MT4 | PCI DSS, FCA | Barga da ƙarfi | high | Doguwa da tabbatarwa |
cTrader | PCI DSS, FCA | Barga da sauri | high | Gajere kuma mai tsabta |
6. Takaitaccen Bayanin Ribobi & Fursunoni
A cikin wannan sashe, za mu taƙaita mahimman ƙarfi da raunin kowane dandali a cikin tebur madaidaici kuma a takaice. Za mu kuma haskaka manufa trader iri ga kowane dandali bisa ga fasali da kuma iyawarsu.
Platform | ribobi | fursunoni | Manufa TradeNau'in r |
MT4 | UI mai sauƙi kuma mai hankali
Faɗin kayan kida masu yawa Ƙarfin sarrafa kansa da ikon ciniki na algorithmic Babban ɗakin karatu na EAs da alamomin al'ada Babban jituwa tare da brokers da na'urori Babban tsaro da aminci |
Mafi girman yadawa da kwamitocin
Ƙananan nau'ikan tsari da nau'ikan kariya Ƙananan ƙayyadaddun lokaci da nau'in ginshiƙi Ƙananan siffofi da tallavantages M inganci da amincin na brokers Karancin yaren rubutu na zamani da mai sauƙin amfani |
Traders waɗanda suka fi son dandamali mai sauƙi kuma sananne
Traders wanene trade forex da kuma CFDs akan kayan aiki daban-daban Traders waɗanda ke amfani da dabarun ciniki ta atomatik da EAs Traders wanda ke neman fadi da kewayon broker zaɓuɓɓuka da nau'ikan asusun Traders wanda ke darajar tsaro da aminci |
cTrader | Na zamani da nagartaccen UI
Ƙananan shimfidawa da kwamitocin Nau'in tsari mafi girma da nau'ikan kariya Mafi girman lokutan lokaci da nau'ikan ginshiƙi Keɓaɓɓen fasali da tallavantages High quality da amincin na brokers Ƙarin yaren rubutun zamani da mai sauƙin amfani |
Iyakantaccen kewayon kayan ciniki
Mafi girman mafi ƙarancin asusu da kuɗin rashin aiki Ƙananan bambancin asusu da sassauci Ƙananan ɗakin karatu na cBots da alamomin al'ada Ƙananan daidaituwa tare da brokers da na'urori Ƙananan rabon kasuwa da shahara Gajere kuma ƙarancin kafa rikodin waƙa |
Traders waɗanda suka fi son dandamali mafi ci gaba da sassauƙa
Traders wanene trade forex da kuma CFDs akan kayan aikin da aka zaɓa Traders waɗanda ke amfani da nau'ikan tsari na ci gaba da nau'ikan kariya Traders wanda ke neman mafi girma inganci da amincin brokers Traders waɗanda ke darajar keɓantattun siffofi da tallavantages |